Two visions on how to fight online child abuse in Europe

The encrypted messenger service was quick to condemn the committee’s proposal. Julia Weiss, a spokeswoman for the Swiss messaging app Threema, said the company was unwilling to compromise the privacy of its users in any way. “Building a surveillance system that actively scans for all private content is a terrible idea when apple came up with itnow that’s a bad idea,” Add to Will Cathcart, head of WhatsApp, posted on Twitter. August 2021, Apple announces a proposal Scanned photos of its users for child sexual abuse material, but after fierce criticism, Indefinite delay Those plans a month later.

But European Home Affairs Commissioner Ilva Johnson has been pursuing the law. “I am ready to hear criticism from companies because there may be no profit in detecting child sexual abuse material and protecting children, but it is necessary,” she told a news conference on Wednesday. She added that the tools used to perform any scans had to be technologies with the least invasion of privacy, and they had to be selected in consultation with data protection authorities.

Johansson’s proposal does not define what type of technology these companies should use to scan messages. The reason for this, the commissioner said, was to make new privacy-friendly solutions invent legislation not outdated. The law will also prompt businesses to devote more resources to creating tools they will be authorized to use later, her supporters say. “I am increasingly convinced that if the environment is right, if there is a normative legal framework that will protect children and young people, then companies and solutions can be created and generated that can eliminate this crisis,” Paul Zeitz, executive The coordinator said: The Brave Movement, a group representing survivors of child sexual violence.

But privacy groups say that approach means building legislation on impossible technology. “Commissioner Johansson said publicly that you can scan encrypted information securely and with full respect for privacy, and that doesn’t matter,” Jakubowska said. “That doesn’t hold true.”

The regulation still needs approval from the European Parliament and EU member states, which could take years. But critics, including Germany’s Federal Data Protection Commissioner Ulrich Kelber, Commitment Stop the current proposal. “The statute should not exist in this form under any circumstances as certain issues would lead to serious interference with the resolution of fundamental rights,” he said on Thursday.

Johnson, however, remained unmoved. In an interview with Wired, she described her struggle with child sexual abuse as a very personal enterprise. “As a mother, I feel obligated to protect my children,” she said. “As an adult, I have an obligation to protect all children. As a politician, when I have the power to introduce legislation to protect children, I think I have a moral obligation to introduce that legislation.”

Other members of the European Parliament accuse Johnson of causing a heated debate in the debate hard to criticize details in the law without giving the impression that they don’t care about children who are being abused.

However, the commissioner can claim supporters among child sex abuse survivors who say they are impressed by her strong words and simple language on a topic that still feels taboo.

“When you’re a survivor, it feels really good to have a very strong political leader, talking about shame, talking about trauma, talking about the impact of child sexual abuse,” said Mié Kohiyama, a French child sexual abuse survivor who was also abused earlier this year. Part of the Courageous Movement founded at the time. “It’s so important to us.”

Source link