Sports stars screamed out at the risk of cultural cancellation because transgender swimmers broke female records

Challenging the right of male-born transgender athletes to compete with women is a good way to get themselves cancelled, but more and more people in sports circles are taking the risk of becoming swimmers at the University of Pennsylvania Leah Thomas Run on the college record book.

The latest to stand up is Erika Brown, a two-time Olympic medalist. According to reports, she issued a statement on Instagram Stories last week against the biological males in women’s sports, making her the first to participate in the competition. US team swimmer.

“I don’t want to create any hatred, just to speak up for the right things,” Brown said in a comment reprinted by SwimSwam and Swimming World. “We cannot allow trans women to compete with physical women.”

A sports icon who supports Brown-and recognizes the stakes-is tennis superstar Martina Navratilova, who wrote on Twitter on Thursday: “Erica Brown is a brave woman. She can speak bluntly while playing. She had better not be cancelled by anyone because of this!!!”

23-year-old Brown won the silver and bronze medals at the 2021 Tokyo Olympics. He joined this small but growing team of sports figures, risking condemnation and ignoring sports authorities, universities, and cultural awakening trends.

Other voices include Hall of Fame swimming coach Dave Salo; 11-time national swimmer Jerry Shanto, And longtime U.S. swimming official Cynthia Mirren, He withdrew in November to protest allowing male-born athletes to swim with women.

The catalyst is 22 years old Thomas, Who broke the record she The first season of the University of Pennsylvania Women’s Swimming Team, positioning themselves as participating in the competition NCAA Records held by Katie Ledecky and Missy Franklin.

Thomas After playing for the men’s team for three years, she was allowed to play with the women’s team through a year of testosterone suppression NCAA, Brown condemned as a severely inadequate standard.

“Biological men go through male puberty,” Brown said in her post. “Even if she has transformed, she still has the physiology of a male. A few years of testosterone blockers and estrogen will not change the fact that she will have stronger muscles, a larger heart, and more than a biological female. Big lung capacity.”

Brown concluded: “It’s time to start standing up for the women’s sport so that we don’t lose what many people have fought for before. I hope this can help inspire others to speak up.”

This sentiment runs counter to the influential LGBTQ movement, which fights for the right of transgender athletes to compete based on gender identity and gender at birth.

“Although people may think that this is more about sports, this is actually a broader conversation about the human nature of transgender people and whether we should participate in all aspects of social life, including college sports,” Athlete Ally Policy and Programs Director Anne Lieberman said in a statement on December 17.

Outsports slammed the swimmer’s commotion as an “anti-transgender panic,” while LGBTQ Nation blamed the “right-wing backlash” on “anti-transgender advocates.”

People on the other side insist that their beef is not a transgender athlete, for example Thomas, Who followed NCAA Rules, but the sports management agency has cleared the way for male-born swimmers to compete with females.

Salo, who retired as the head coach of the USC swimming team last year, said most coaches agree NCAA The policy is wrong, but it is worried that taking such a position will have social and professional consequences.

“I would say that most coaches would agree with me,” Salo told the Washington Times. “But again, they are very worried about opposing such things in the university environment because they will be considered transgender or gay. I can tell.”

At the University of Pennsylvania, two female teammates and some parents shared their Thomas Worked with the media last month, but so far, everyone has done so anonymously.

Sports website OutKick said one of the swimmers was “worried she Employability sharing after graduating from university she Honest views on transgender teammates. Another cited “threats from universities, activists, and the political climate.”

The team is also under pressure to avoid talking to the media and support Thomas, They said, even she Blow away the competition.

At a conference at the University of Akron last month, Thomas Set the best time in the country in the 200 freestyle; broke the 500 freestyle record of an Ivy League school and won 1,650 freestyle championships in an astonishing 38 seconds. she It also maintains the best time for the top 500 in the United States.

Swimmers criticized the University of Pennsylvania swimming coach Mike Schnur, but Salo said that any coach complaints to the government would endanger his career.

“I know that the anonymous comment made by a team member is that he only cares about winning,” Salo said. “But I think if he goes to his government and says that I can’t accept this, his status as the head coach of the University of Pennsylvania may be affected. So you have to take this into consideration.”

Chanto, Who won three NCAA Auburn won the national championship in the mid-2000s and appeared on Fox’s “The Ingraham Angle” last month, where she The sports authorities are accused of “ignoring” and “completely discriminating against” female athletes.

she Even do she Speaking loudly is “very scary”, especially for young athletes who are still participating in competitive swimming.

“Listen, the reality is that I am a full-time mother of two children. I have a relationship with swimming. I have developed relationships with hundreds of people who are still involved in the sport,” Chanto Tell the Washington Times. “But some people don’t have the luxury I have. If I say it, I hope my whole livelihood will not be ruined. This culture of cancellation is very scary, I dare not say it out loud.”

LGBTQ advocates counter that transgender athletes face their own social minefields, including being ridiculed or accused of cheating; being misunderstood in the media and plagued by aggressive personal and medical issues.

“Athletes will be misled by the mass media of certain media such as the New York Post and Daily Mail,” Outsports writer Carly Webb said in an article on December 9. “These groups and others will put your dead name and pre-transition photos throughout the story without your consent. Athletes will also receive a lot of insults on social media, from unknown to well-known.”

forward ThomasThe best example is Laurel Hubbard (Laurel Hubbard), this male-born New Zealand weightlifter, after becoming the first openly transgender Olympic athlete, was scorned last year for competing with women and was praised. Pioneer of LGBTQ. She did not win a medal after failing to complete the lift.

This NCAA In response to state laws prohibiting male-born athletes from participating in women’s sports, the state supports transgender athletes and announced in April that it will only allow tournaments to be held in “safe, healthy, and non-discriminatory” locations.

However, in October, the human rights movement accused NCAA Softball games are allowed in Alabama, Arkansas, and Tennessee, all of which have passed such laws.

“Human Rights Movement Appeals NCAA HRC interim chairman Joni Madison (Joni Madison) stated in a statement on October 1 that by refusing to consider the top four host cities in states that ban transgender sports, the health and safety of transgender athletes are respected.

HRC, the nation’s largest LGBTQ group, has not yet Thomas condition. The Washington Times has been contacted for comment.

Beth Stelzer, head of Save Women’s Sports, said that transgender sports have had a huge impact on mainstream media and social media, but believes that the trend is changing, thanks to Chanto, Mirren And other people like them.

“I think we will see a surge in support. We just need a safe space for people to talk freely because it is such a toxic environment,” Stelzer said in a podcast on Sunday. “This movement bullied the people who spoke, but we finally got to the point where the bullies could no longer shut us up. We have enough people.”



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.